top of page

Why open relationships fail: a polyamory therapist on opening from strength or deficit

Jul 24, 2025
8 min read

Updated November 2026


If you're thinking about opening your relationship because things between you aren't working, read this first.


It usually goes like this. You've had the same fight for months. Intimacy has gone flat. One of you brings up ethical nonmonogamy, ENM for short, and suddenly it feels like a door out. Maybe someone new will bring back the spark. Maybe getting needs met elsewhere will take the pressure off.


One partner is usually more excited about it than the other. Both of you are hoping it'll fix something.


Open relationships most often fail when couples open from a place of deficit, using new partners to patch problems they haven't solved together. ENM works when it's built on a relationship that's already secure, communicative, and honest about capacity.


I work with couples and polycules through my ENM and polyamory therapy, and I believe polyamory can be a deeply fulfilling way to love. That's exactly why I'm frank about when it isn't the right move yet.


Two people having an intimate, serious conversation while embracing, representing couples working through relationship challenges in therapy
Hard conversations belong at the start of opening up.

In this guide



Why do open relationships fail?


Most open relationships that fail were opened to fix something. The new partner becomes a solution to boredom, resentment, or distance, and the original problem rides along into every new connection.


The other common reasons:


  • One partner agreed under pressure. A reluctant yes turns into resentment fast.

  • Nobody negotiated the details. Time, sex, safer sex practices, and what gets shared all stayed vague.

  • No plan for jealousy. Jealousy is normal in ENM. Couples who expect it to disappear get blindsided.

  • The new person was an afterthought. A third partner is a whole person with needs, and treating them like a fix hurts everyone.


Open relationships can work. The starting point matters more than almost anything else.


The "opening up will fix us" myth


The biggest myth is that adding partners will solve what's already broken between the two of you. Here are the reasons I hear most:


  • "We need more excitement and passion."

  • "If I get my needs met elsewhere, I won't be so demanding."

  • "This will force us to communicate better."

  • "Other people will show us what we're missing."


Each of these treats a new partner as the repair. That puts a lot of weight on someone who didn't sign up to fix your relationship.


The band aid approach


Opening up to avoid core issues is a band aid on a deep wound. The distraction feels good for a while, and the wound keeps getting worse underneath. Communication breakdowns, trust problems, and emotional distance all come with you, and they get louder with more people involved.


The scarcity trap


Scarcity sounds like "we're not getting enough from each other, so let's find it elsewhere." It locates the problem in what's missing instead of in how you relate. ENM that lasts usually starts from abundance: a secure relationship with enough connection and energy to share.


Why ENM amplifies existing problems


Ethical nonmonogamy asks for exceptional communication. If you can't navigate conflict, name your needs, or stay close with one partner, more partners add pressure to every crack.


Black and white photo of a couple engaged in focused conversation, demonstrating attachment focused therapy communication techniques
Communication patterns you have now follow you into every new relationship.

Communication issues multiply


Can't talk about money without a fight? Wait until you're negotiating time, attention, and sex across several relationships. Defensiveness, stonewalling, and mind reading all scale up.


Trust and security issues get louder


If you already struggle with trust or fear of abandonment, watching your partner build intimacy with someone else will hit those exact spots. The checking, the jealousy spirals, and the worst case thinking all intensify.


Emotional intimacy gets harder to find


Many couples who open up are already struggling to be close. Instead of learning to be vulnerable with each other, they look for closeness somewhere else, and the primary relationship drifts further. Partners describe feeling like roommates who compare notes about their dates.


What attachment patterns have to do with everything


Attachment style is the blueprint you learned early for how to connect, and it comes with you into every relationship you add.


Anxious attachment and ENM


Anxious attachment means you crave closeness and fear losing it. More partners can look like more sources of love. In practice, the anxiety often spreads: you start watching several people for signs of rejection and needing reassurance from all of them.


Avoidant attachment and ENM


Avoidant attachment means you protect yourself by keeping some distance. ENM can feel like a way to have intimacy and independence at once. The risk is using other relationships to step away from conflict in your primary one, which creates more distance right where you need connection.


The pattern I see most: an anxious partner reaches, an avoidant partner pulls back, and there's always a reason for it. The avoidant partner usually needs space to process so they can talk without feeling rushed. The anxious partner usually needs verbal reassurance and to feel prioritized. Adding partners makes those competing needs louder, so you need a plan for who gets the space first in a given moment, and you need more than one person to lean on.


Disorganized attachment and ENM


Disorganized attachment, which is common with trauma histories, means closeness feels both wanted and dangerous. ENM can feel thrilling and terrifying at the same time, and without support it becomes one more place for old patterns to replay.


Where neurodivergence fits


ADHD can make novelty and new relationship energy, or NRE, especially intoxicating. Rejection sensitive dysphoria, or RSD, an intense physical pain response to perceived rejection, can make a partner's date feel unbearable. Neither rules out ENM. Both need to be planned for. I cover this in the neurodivergent guide to polyamory.


The prerequisites for healthy polyamory


The question I ask every couple is this: are you opening from a place of strength or deficit?


Signs you're opening from deficit


  • The same arguments keep repeating with no resolution.

  • You're hoping a new person will bring closeness back, the same way some couples hope a baby or a dog will.

  • Fights turn into a blame game.

  • Infidelity happened, and ENM is how you're trying to make it okay.

  • Nobody has thought about what you can actually offer a new partner, or where they'd fit long term.


Signs you're opening from strength


  • Your relationship is in a genuinely good place right now.

  • You can each name your own strengths and weaknesses.

  • You're clear on your future together, whether that's living together or keeping separate homes.

  • You're comfortable in your dynamic, and trust has been built over time.

  • You're honest about your emotional, physical, and mental capacity.

  • You already talk openly and check in regularly.


What secure looks like day to day


  • You can talk about hard topics without losing your shit.

  • You trust each other's commitment.

  • You feel safe being vulnerable.

  • You have a reliable way to repair after conflict.

  • Both of you want ENM for its own sake, and neither of you is agreeing to avoid a breakup.


How to actually fix your relationship first


Before you open up, walk through this evaluation together. It's the same one I use with couples in session.


  1. Where are we actually at? Describe your relationship as it is right now, including the fights you keep having.

  2. Are we opening from strength or deficit? Use the lists above and answer honestly, each of you separately first.

  3. What can we offer other partners? Think about time, energy, emotional availability, and where a new person would fit in your life.

  4. How will we show up for them? Decide how you'll treat a new partner as a whole person with their own needs.

  5. What do they need to know about us? Your agreements, your other relationships, and anything that affects their safety and choices.


If the answers point to deficit, that's useful information. Start here:


Start with attachment work


Get curious about how you each learned to connect, what sets off your alarm, and what you need to feel secure. This is where I spend most of my time with couples considering ENM.


Build real communication skills


  • Speak from vulnerability instead of defensiveness.

  • Stay regulated during conflict, or agree on a pause and come back.

  • Make room for your partner's experience without fixing it.

  • Practice repair when conversations go sideways.


Do your individual work


Each of you is responsible for your own patterns. That might mean individual therapy for anxiety, trauma, or burnout, learning to meet some of your own needs, or building a life and identity outside the relationship.


Practice in lower stakes places


Try new boundary and communication skills with friends and family first. They'll feel familiar when the stakes get higher.


Two people in casual clothing appearing relaxed and happy together, showing the results of successful relationship communication work
The skills that make ENM work start in everyday conversations.

Scripts for the "should we open up?" conversation


  • "I want to talk about this when we're both calm, not in the middle of a fight."

  • "I'm curious about ENM. I also want to be honest that part of me hopes it'll fix things."

  • "I'm not a yes yet. I need to understand what you're hoping it changes."

  • "What would make you feel secure if we tried this?"

  • "Before we meet anyone, can we write down our agreements?"


When ENM might be right for you


I'm not anti ENM. When people are ready for it, ethical nonmonogamy can be incredibly fulfilling. Couples who do well with it usually have these in common.


They're motivated by abundance


They have a strong, secure relationship they want to expand.


They have solid individual emotional health


Each partner has done personal work and can own their reactions.


They communicate well under pressure


They can stay connected during conflict and repair quickly.


They're glad about their partner's other relationships


They want their partner to experience love and joy with other people, even when it stirs up hard feelings.


They know ENM is more work


Multiple relationships take more time, energy, and emotional bandwidth, and they plan for that.


If you want a structure for all of this, I believe in written relationship agreements as a living document. My Relationship Agreement Package walks couples and polycules through building one together.


Questions people ask about open relationships


Why is an open relationship so hard?


It asks you to handle jealousy, scheduling, safer sex, and other people's feelings all at once, using communication skills most of us were never taught. If your relationship has unresolved conflict, ENM puts pressure on exactly those places.


Can opening a relationship save a marriage?


Rarely, when it's used as the fix. Couples who open up to save their marriage usually carry their existing problems into new relationships. Couples who repair first and then decide to open up have a much better foundation.


What percentage of open relationships fail?


There's no reliable number. Research on ENM is still limited, and studies define open relationships in different ways. What's consistent is that the reasons for opening up, and the skills couples bring, shape how it goes.


Is an open relationship cheating?


No. Cheating is breaking the agreements you made. An open relationship is a new set of agreements that both partners actually consent to. Breaking those agreements still counts as a betrayal.


What are the disadvantages of an open relationship?


More time pressure, more emotional processing, more scheduling, and more conversations about safer sex and boundaries. It also tends to expose problems that monogamy let you ignore.


The bottom line


When your relationship is struggling, opening up can feel like adding more love and more possibility. The problems you're avoiding come along into every new connection, though. ENM is graduate level relationship work, and it goes best when the basics are already solid.


There's no template. Every couple I work with works differently, and some decide ENM is right for them while others decide it isn't. Both are good outcomes when you get there on purpose.



Where to go from here


Learn more about my ENM and polyamory therapy. If you're neurodivergent, read the neurodivergent guide to polyamory. If jealousy hits you hard, when you feel not chosen goes deeper.


I offer therapy to adults living in California. If you're somewhere else, the tools in this post are still yours to use.



About Maya


Professional headshot of Maya Attia, licensed marriage and family therapist specializing in polyamory and attachment focused relationship therapy
Maya Attia, LMFT, online therapist in California.

Maya Attia, LMFT, offers online therapy across California for neurodivergent adults, kink and BDSM, and ethical nonmonogamy. I help couples and polycules build secure foundations, whatever structure they choose. Learn more about me and my approach.


Maya Attia, LMFT, California license 139693


This article is for education and doesn't replace individual or couples therapy.

 
 
 

Comments


loader,gif

Talk with Maya is owned and operated by Talk with Maya Marriage and Family Therapy, a California Professional corporation specializing in Marriage and Family Therapy.

Maya Attia, LMFT, provides online therapy for neurodivergent adults and couples throughout California. Together, we shift the patterns you've been stuck in so you can build relationships, a body, and an identity that actually fit who you are.

Maya Attia, LMFT #139693

© 2026 Talk With Maya

bottom of page